7 Ways to Get a Mortgage Without PMI in Richmond, VA

Duane Buziak

Duane Buziak
Mortgage Maestro | NMLS #1110647 | Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC
Licensed mortgage broker serving Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, Georgia, and Washington, specializing in VA home loans and first-time homebuyer programs.

Private mortgage insurance, or PMI, is the monthly charge on a conventional loan when your down payment is under 20%. In Richmond it can add $100 to $300 to a payment, and many buyers assume 20% down is the only way out. It is not. VA loans, lender-paid structures, a second loan, and a planned removal date all work for the right buyer, and each has a cost of its own. Duane Buziak walks Church Hill, Fan, Henrico, Chesterfield and Midlothian buyers through seven of them below. Every dollar figure here is an illustration with stated assumptions, not a quote. Rates, insurer pricing and program terms change, so treat anything marked “as of November 2026” as a snapshot.

1. Put 20% Down

PMI protects the investor when your equity is thin. Once your loan is 80% or less of the purchase price (80% loan-to-value, or LTV), a conventional loan does not require it. This is the cleanest route: no insurance, no extra rate, no fee to remove later.

Suppose, for illustration, a Church Hill rowhouse at $450,000. Twenty percent is $90,000, leaving a $360,000 loan. At an assumed 6.5% on a 30-year fixed, principal and interest is about $2,275. Now compare 5% down: $22,500 down, a $427,500 loan, and about $2,702 in principal and interest. Add PMI at an assumed 0.60% a year (about $214 a month) and the payment is roughly $2,916. The gap is about $640 a month, and about $67,500 of extra cash up front buys it.

To put it into practice:

  1. Calculate the 20% target for your price range, including closing costs on top.
  2. Confirm where the money comes from. Large deposits generally need a paper trail, and funds sitting in your account for about two months (seasoning) simplify underwriting.
  3. Decide how much cash you want left after closing.
  4. Ask for a quote showing both the 20% and 5% scenarios side by side.

The common mistake is draining every dollar to hit 80% and closing with nothing in reserve. A rowhouse built in the early 1900s will eventually need a roof, plumbing or HVAC work, and a first-year repair on a credit card can cost more than the PMI you avoided.

Measure the monthly payment saved against the PMI scenario, and the months of housing payments still in your account after closing. If reserves fall under a few months, a smaller down payment paired with another strategy below may serve you better.

2. VA Loan

VA loans carry no monthly mortgage insurance. Instead there is a one-time funding fee, which can be financed into the loan, and veterans receiving VA disability compensation and certain others are exempt. The VA guaranty is what lets a loan with little or no down payment avoid PMI. Current fee percentages are on VA.gov’s funding fee page.

For illustration, imagine a Chesterfield buyer purchasing at $400,000 with $0 down. Assume a first-use funding fee of 2.15% (verify the current table; as of November 2026 it should be confirmed on VA.gov). That is $8,600, financed to a $408,600 loan. At an assumed 6.5%, principal and interest is about $2,583 with nothing out of pocket for the down payment. A conventional 5% loan on the same home is $380,000, about $2,402 plus roughly $190 of assumed PMI, so about $2,592, and it needs $20,000 down. The monthly cost is nearly identical, but VA gets there without the cash.

Steps to take:

  1. Request your Certificate of Eligibility through VA.gov or have it pulled for you.
  2. Confirm whether you are exempt from the funding fee.
  3. Get a soft-pull review first, so you can see where your score sits with no hard inquiry on your file.
  4. Compare VA loan terms across multiple loan sources, since added requirements on credit score and debt ratios vary.

Two mistakes recur. One is treating VA as free and ignoring the funding fee. The other is assuming a modest score rules you out without checking; some VA programs go well below what conventional loans accept.

Measure the total monthly payment and the funding fee dollars against the conventional-with-PMI quote. If you plan to stay a long time, remember the fee is a cost on the whole loan balance, so compare it honestly.

3. LPMI: Pay for Mortgage Insurance Through the Rate

Lender-paid mortgage insurance (LPMI) is the industry term for a structure where the insurance premium is covered by a higher interest rate instead of a separate monthly line. Your statement shows no PMI, but you are paying for it in the rate.

For illustration, take a $400,000 Henrico purchase with 5% down, a $380,000 loan. With borrower-paid PMI (BPMI) at an assumed 6.5% rate and 0.60% PMI, the payment is about $2,592. With LPMI at an assumed 6.875% and no PMI, it is about $2,496, roughly $96 less each month. Those are placeholders; use real paired quotes.

The catch is permanence. BPMI can be cancelled. In this example, the balance reaches 80% of $400,000 around year ten, and after that the BPMI payment drops to about $2,402. The LPMI rate stays, so you then pay about $94 a month more than the BPMI borrower for the life of the loan, unless you refinance. In this simplified math, the early savings are only caught up after roughly two decades. If you expect to sell or refinance within ten years, LPMI can win. If you plan to stay, it often loses.

How to evaluate it:

  1. Request paired quotes for BPMI and LPMI on the same loan.
  2. Subtract the monthly payments and calculate the breakeven month.
  3. Compare that against how long you realistically expect to hold the home, and whether a refinance is likely.

The common mistake is choosing LPMI for a long-term hold without realizing the higher rate cannot be cancelled. Measure the breakeven month and the total interest plus insurance paid over your expected holding period.

4. 80/10/10 Piggyback

In a piggyback, a first mortgage covers 80% of the price, a second loan covers 10%, and you put 10% down. Because the first loan sits at 80% LTV, it needs no PMI. You are swapping insurance for a second payment.

Suppose a Midlothian new-construction home at $500,000. The first mortgage is $400,000, the second is $50,000, and you put down $50,000. At an assumed 6.5% on the first loan, principal and interest is about $2,528. Assume the second is a fixed 20-year loan at 9%, about $450 a month. Combined, that is roughly $2,978. The alternative is a single 90% LTV loan of $450,000 at 6.5% (about $2,844) plus assumed PMI of 0.80% (about $300), totaling about $3,144. The piggyback saves roughly $166 a month in this scenario.

Walk through it like this:

  1. Confirm that a second lien or HELOC is available for your property type and credit profile right now, since availability tightens and loosens.
  2. Compare fixed versus variable second-loan terms, including any draw and repayment periods.
  3. Model both combined payments at today’s quotes and at a higher second-loan rate.

The pitfall is a second loan whose rate is variable or simply higher than you assumed. A few percentage points on $50,000 can erase the savings. Also, unlike PMI, the second loan does not fall away at a threshold; you must pay it down.

Measure the combined monthly payment against the single loan with PMI, and keep a written plan for paying off the second loan.

5. Down Payment Assistance and Grants

Assistance rarely eliminates PMI by itself, but it can move you into a lower LTV tier, and insurers price PMI by tier. Less loan and a cheaper rate stack together.

For illustration, imagine a first-time buyer in the Fan or Henrico with $20,000 of savings and a $10,000 grant on a $400,000 home. That is 7.5% down and a $370,000 loan, instead of 5% down and a $380,000 loan. Assume PMI of 0.90% at 95% LTV versus 0.75% at 92.5% LTV. The monthly PMI falls from about $285 to about $231, and principal and interest drops by about $63 at an assumed 6.5%. Total monthly relief is roughly $117, from tier and loan size together. The tier rates are assumptions; check a current insurer rate card.

To use it:

  1. Check your eligibility for Virginia Housing programs, then ask about broker-sourced grants with no income limit.
  2. Read the repayment terms. Some assistance is a forgivable or deferred second lien, and some must be repaid if you sell or refinance.
  3. Verify current funding, since programs can pause when money runs out.
  4. Rerun the PMI quote with the assistance included.

The two common mistakes are expecting assistance alone to reach 20% down, and overlooking program rules and repayment terms that affect a later refinance. Measure the change in LTV and in monthly PMI cost once the assistance is applied. If the monthly figure barely moves, the grant is still worth having, but it is not a PMI strategy.

6. Soft-Pull Score Optimization

When PMI cannot be avoided, its price still moves. Insurers set premiums by credit score band and LTV, so a higher score band at the time you lock can reduce the premium for the entire period you pay it. That includes FHA-style pricing differences too, though the mechanics vary.

For illustration, suppose you carry $9,000 across credit cards with $20,000 in total limits, 45% utilization. Paying that to $5,000 brings utilization to 25%, below the roughly 30% level often cited as a threshold. Whether that jumps you into a better PMI tier depends on where your score sits relative to the insurer’s bands, which is exactly why you check before you apply.

A practical sequence:

  1. Start with the NoTouch Credit Pull soft credit pull mortgage review, so you see your score picture without a hard inquiry.
  2. Pay down revolving balances, prioritizing cards closest to their limits.
  3. Dispute errors with the bureaus and get corrections documented.
  4. Re-check after balances report, then proceed to the formal application.

The mistake that costs people most is applying through several parties at once, each pulling hard inquiries, before knowing the score picture. Reporting dates matter too: a balance you paid last week may not show for weeks.

Measure your score movement across PMI pricing tiers, and compare the quoted PMI premium before and after. If a 15-point change does not cross a pricing band, the effort may be better spent on a different strategy.

7. Early PMI Removal and Refinance

Conventional PMI is not permanent. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, you can request cancellation when your balance reaches 80% of the original value, and it terminates automatically at 78% on the original schedule. The CFPB explains the rules. Appreciation can speed this up.

For illustration, a Fan buyer purchases at $450,000 with 5% down, a $427,500 loan. After three years the balance is roughly $412,000. If a new appraisal supports $520,000, the LTV is about 79%. Many servicers allow cancellation based on current value, often with a minimum seasoning period and an appraisal, though rules vary by investor. If the loan was FHA, mortgage insurance premium (MIP) works differently: for most loans with less than 10% down, it lasts for the life of the loan, per HUD.gov. Refinancing into a conventional loan can remove it once your equity supports that.

Steps to follow:

  1. Track your amortization schedule and note the months until 80% and 78%.
  2. Submit your cancellation request in writing at 80% of original value.
  3. If you rely on appreciation, order the appraisal your servicer requires.
  4. Compare refinance options, including cash-out up to 90%, against the cost of the refinance itself, which has closing costs.

The most common error is paying PMI past eligibility because no one asked for cancellation. Measure your current LTV, the months until the 80% and 78% marks, and the monthly savings once PMI is gone.

Which Path to Start With, and What Duane Buziak Recommends Next

Start with the two steps that cost nothing and shape every other option: a soft-pull score check and a VA eligibility review. A mortgage pre approval without hard pull lets you see your numbers before anything touches your credit. From there, compare 20% down, LPMI and a piggyback side by side on your actual price range with Duane Buziak at 804-212-8663. Ready to secure your dream home with Richmond’s most trusted mortgage expert? Get your personalized rate comparison today with no credit impact and discover why hundreds of local families choose Duane Buziak for stress-free mortgage solutions backed by 24/7 support and the fastest close times in the area.