By the end of this guide you will know how to compare mortgage rates from multiple lenders on the same loan, with a side-by-side sheet that shows which offer is cheapest for a Richmond-area purchase or refinance. Before you start, gather two recent pay stubs or income documents, your last two months of bank statements, a rough target price (Church Hill, The Fan, Henrico, Chesterfield, and Midlothian all land in different bands), and a general idea of your down payment.
By Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647
Step 1: Define the Exact Loan You Want Quoted
Quotes only compare when they describe the same loan. Write down these variables before you contact anyone:
- Loan type: conventional, FHA, VA, or a Non-QM option such as DSCR or Bank Statement.
- Term: 30-year or 15-year fixed.
- Price and down payment: the actual numbers, not a range.
- Occupancy: primary home, second home, or investment property. Pricing differs for each.
- Lock period: 30, 45, or 60 days, based on your expected closing date.
Anchor the scenario to a real property. A Church Hill rowhouse and a Midlothian single-family home produce very different loan sizes. The loan amount also decides whether you sit comfortably under the 2026 baseline conforming limit of $832,750, which applies in Henrico and Chesterfield (confirm the figure on the FHFA site). Above that limit you move into jumbo pricing, and rates and guidelines change.
The most common mistake is comparing a 30-year fixed with no points against a quote that includes points, or against a 15-year term. Decide now whether you are willing to pay points. If you are not, ask every source for a no-points quote. If you are open to them, ask for both versions.
Last, choose your decision metric before you see any numbers. Pick one primary measure, whether that is monthly payment, APR, or cash to close, and a tiebreaker. Otherwise the first attractive rate you see will quietly pick the metric for you.
Step 2: Check Your Credit Without Hurting It
A hard inquiry happens when a creditor pulls your full report to make a lending decision, and it can lower your score slightly. A soft pull is a review that does not appear to other creditors and does not affect your score. Duane Buziak uses the NoTouch Credit Pull, so you can get a mortgage pre approval without hard pull and see where you stand before any shopping begins. It is a no credit hit mortgage application at the start, which removes the fear that keeps many buyers from comparing offers.
Shopping later in the process is usually safe too. Scoring models generally treat multiple mortgage inquiries within a short window as a single inquiry, but the length of that window varies by model. The CFPB’s home-buying guidance encourages comparing offers, so keep your formal applications close together, ideally within a week or two.
Know which scores matter. Mortgage scoring differs from the free score in a banking app, and those apps often show a different model than the ones mortgage investors use. VantageScore 4.0 is among the models now referenced in the mortgage space, but acceptance depends on the investor and loan program, so confirm the current status with whoever is quoting you (as of this writing, FHFA and the GSEs have been phasing in additional models).
Flexibility exists if your score is lower than you would like. Some VA loans can work with scores as low as 500 when the broker has investors that allow it. That is a possibility, not a promise. Approval depends on your full file, including income, assets, and the property.
Step 3: Collect Quotes From Several Sources the Same Day
Rates move daily and sometimes within a day. If you collect one quote on Monday and another on Thursday, you are comparing markets as well as offers. Request every quote on the same day, and write down the date and time each one was given.
Aim for a mix of three kinds of sources:
- A broker who can shop hundreds of lenders at one time. This covers the wholesale market in a single conversation.
- A direct online provider. Rocket and Movement are two names borrowers commonly look at, and either gives you a retail benchmark.
- A local bank or credit union where you already have an account.
Give each source the identical scenario from Step 1: same loan type, price, down payment, occupancy, and lock period. If one source quotes a 45-day lock and another a 30-day lock, you are no longer comparing the same thing, so correct it on the spot.
Ask each source for a written Loan Estimate, not a verbal rate. Under federal rules the lender must deliver a Loan Estimate within three business days after receiving a complete application (see the CFPB’s Loan Estimate explainer). A complete application means name, income, Social Security number, property address, estimated value, and loan amount.
Tip: if you want to see pricing before committing to a formal application, ask whether the provider can run a soft pull mortgage broker scenario first. You get realistic numbers without adding inquiries.
Step 4: Line Up the Loan Estimates Page by Page
The Loan Estimate is a standardized three-page form, so the same information sits in the same place on every quote. Work through it in this order:
- Page 1: interest rate, APR, monthly principal and interest, and estimated cash to close. The Projected Payments section shows whether mortgage insurance or escrow is included.
- Page 2, Section A (Origination Charges): the broker or lender compensation, points, and fees. This is where two quotes with the same rate often differ the most.
- Section B (Services You Cannot Shop For): items such as the appraisal and credit report, chosen by the provider.
- Section C (Services You Can Shop For): title and settlement services. You can pick your own provider here, so you can often change this number.
- Section E (Taxes and Other Government Fees): recording fees and transfer taxes, which should be nearly identical across quotes for the same property.
Do not compare rate alone. Two quotes at the same rate can differ by thousands of dollars in origination charges or points, and a lower rate that costs more upfront is not automatically the cheaper loan.
Build a simple sheet with one row per quote and columns for rate, APR, points, lender credits, monthly payment, and cash to close. Add a column for the quote date and time. The sheet keeps you honest when the numbers start to blur.
One caution on wording. You will see “lender credits” on the form, and some marketing implies that a credit means closing is free. It does not. A credit usually trades against a higher interest rate, so you pay for it over time. Ask about no-out-of-pocket closing options, then check what rate comes with them.
Step 5: Run a Worked Dollar Comparison
Start with a realistic price band. Look up a current median for the neighborhood you are targeting, such as The Fan or Church Hill, on Zillow or through Virginia REALTORS market data, and note the “as of” date. Medians shift monthly, and a rowhouse near Libby Hill Park will not price like a renovated townhome near Monument Avenue.
For this illustration, suppose a $450,000 purchase with 10% down ($45,000), leaving a $405,000 30-year fixed loan. The three offers below are hypothetical, not actual quotes, and the rates are placeholders chosen to show the math.
- Offer A: 6.00% with 1 point ($4,050 upfront). Monthly P&I: about $2,428. Five-year cost (payments plus points): about $149,741. Ten-year cost: about $295,432.
- Offer B: 6.25% with no points. Monthly P&I: about $2,494. Five-year cost: about $149,620. Ten-year cost: about $299,240.
- Offer C: 6.50% with a $3,000 lender credit. Monthly P&I: about $2,560. Five-year cost: about $150,593. Ten-year cost: about $304,186.
These totals ignore principal paydown and assume all other fees are equal. Now find the break-even. Offer A saves about $65 a month over Offer B, so $4,050 divided by $65.49 puts break-even near month 62. If you expect to sell or refinance before roughly five years, Offer B wins. Past that, Offer A pulls ahead, by about $3,800 at ten years. Offer C lowers cash to close by $3,000 but costs about $65 more per month than B, so it falls behind B after about 46 months.
The right pick depends on how long you will keep the loan and how much cash you want to hold at closing. Independence also matters at this stage. A broker shopping many wholesale investors can price these three structures against each other, and can offer programs such as Non-QM, DSCR, and Bank Statement HELOC that a single-channel provider may not have.
Step 6: Compare Program Fit, Not Just Price
The cheapest quote can still be the wrong loan. Check whether each source actually offers the program that fits your situation:
- VA loans: review funding fee and entitlement rules on VA.gov. Ask whether the quote includes the funding fee or you have an exemption.
- FHA loans: mortgage insurance rules are on HUD.gov. Compare the upfront and annual premium against a conventional option with private mortgage insurance.
- Down payment assistance: programs such as Dynamo or Turbo DPA exist, but eligibility and terms change, so verify current details before you count on them.
- Cash-out refinance: some programs go up to 90% of value. Confirm the limit on your occupancy type.
Investors should ask about DSCR and bank-statement loans, which qualify you on property cash flow or deposits when tax returns understate income. Also ask about Rental Referral Rewards if you are building a portfolio.
Speed matters in competitive Henrico and Chesterfield offers, where sellers often weigh a clean, quick close. Ask each source for its typical closing timeline, how it orders the appraisal, and whether it works with appraisers who know the local streets. A Midlothian appraisal and a Church Hill rowhouse appraisal each need comparable sales from their own market.
Finally, ask about service. Who will you actually talk to, how fast do they reply, and how do they keep your Realtor updated? A smooth file often depends on these answers more than on a 0.125 difference in rate.
Step 7: Choose, Lock, and Confirm in Writing
Apply your Step 1 metric to the sheet and pick a winner. Then ask the runner-up to match or beat the best quote. Sometimes a fee moves, sometimes nothing does, and it costs you only a phone call.
Before locking, get clear answers on four items:
- Lock length, and whether it covers your realistic closing date.
- The cost of an extension if closing slips.
- Whether a float-down option exists if rates fall, and what it costs.
- What happens to the lock if the appraisal or underwriting runs long.
Get the lock confirmation in writing, then compare your final Loan Estimate to the quote you chose. Certain changed circumstances, such as a revised loan amount or a change in the property value, legally allow a revised estimate, but an unexplained jump in Section A does not. The CFPB’s guidance explains which changes are allowed, and it is worth reading before you sign.
If a revised estimate shows higher fees without a documented reason, ask for the explanation in writing and bring your original comparison sheet to the conversation.
Take Your Comparison Sheet to a Side-by-Side Review
Recheck your final Loan Estimate against your comparison sheet one more time, line by line. If anything differs, resolve it before closing, not at the table. If you would like a second set of eyes, call Duane Buziak at 804-212-8663 for a side-by-side review of your offers or to start a soft pull mortgage broker pre approval.
Ready to secure your dream home with Richmond’s most trusted mortgage expert? Get your personalized rate comparison today with no credit impact and discover why hundreds of local families choose Duane Buziak for stress-free mortgage solutions backed by 24/7 support and the fastest close times in the area. Richmond Mortgages by Duane Buziak is ready when you are.
